M4A4 vs M4A1-S | Which is Better (Finally Answered with Proof)

M4A4 vs M4A1-s which is better has always been a classic debate between CS: GO community. Almost everyone is confused about whether M4A4 is better or M4A1-S is better for the CT Side. The confusion was caused since they both have their pros and cons. So noobs2pro decided to end it once and for all. We checked up and tested both guns. SO here are all the details you need and the final answer is as follows:
CS:GO – Which is better M4A4 OR M4A1-S?
M4A4 M4A1-S
M4A4 – Suited for Aggressive gameplay style
Pros: More Ammo Capacity, and Higher fire rate (So more damage in less time). Best for Mid and close fighters.
Cons: It is Loud and thus easy for players to spot you. In smoke, its easy to notice the gun flash, and thus your position. Higher recoil makes it harder to aim unless you have practiced the recoil pattern well. If you can control AK-47 then this spray is easy
M4A1-S – Suited for Sneaky Players who prefer to stay back and fight.
Pros: The silencer makes it very difficult for enemies to spot you from the sound of the gun. And at long range and in smoke its almost impossible to tell where the shot came from. Lower Recoil makes it very easy to aim and you get perfect headshots with almost zero recoil.
Cons: Low Fire rate so low damage in close-quarter fights. Less ammo capacity so you can out of bullets pretty fast. The silencer sticks out and can give away your location on short corners. Enemy players can see the silencer barrel when you are hidden in certain corners.
M4A1-S or M4A4 – which do CS: GO pros use?
According to HLTV.org stats as of July 2020, the CS: GO M4A4 is historically more popular among pro players. Of all weapons used in pro matches, M4A4 is used 14.41% of the time compared to 5.71% for the M4A1-S.
As far as I know, Pros such as G2 kennyS, G2 Shox, apeX, and Navi Edward often favor the M4A1-S over M4A4 due to its stealth abilities. The other CS: GO pros tend to use the M4A4. Players like FaZe Niko, NaVi s1mple, and Astralis dev1ce, etc are major M4A4 players.

Complete stats about M4A4 and M4A1-S
M4A4 M4A1-S
Stats | M4A4 | M4A1-S |
Ammo Capacity | 30/90 | 25/75 |
Damage | 33 | 33 |
Fire-rate | 11 | 10 |
Recoil Control | 77 | 71 |
Accuracy Range | 30m | 30m |
Armor Penetration | 140 | 140 |
So what do these numbers translate to. Well funny enough both have the same damage so here is how the damage numbers play out:
M4A4 vs M4A1-s comparison

The exact damage stats are as follows: (Damage is same for both guns)

CS:GO M4A4 or M4A1-S – Which should I use?
The final answer depends on your playstyle. For new players and players who prefer using tactics rather than reflexes M4A1-S is better. If you have recoil control and play more on reflexes than M4A4 is better suited for you. It can do more damage in firefights after all. At the end of the day its upto your personal preference what you choose to us.
So now you know which M4 is better suited for you. Let me what your thoughts are about M4A4 VS M4A1-S comparison and which gun you like you to use. Happy Gaming. See you in-game